Benchmark · 3 October 2026

Us vs Office's own repair

The same broken files, given to Microsoft Office's "recover the contents" prompt, to LibreOffice's repair, and to us. Modern and pre-2007 formats alike.

A cat in a lab coat and sunglasses reviewing a clipboard beside towering stacks of spreadsheets
Damaged files

Content recovered from 384 damaged files

Office53%
LibreOffice53%
Us81%

Words and numbers that came back, against the undamaged original. Files that opened at all: Office 65%, LibreOffice 63%, us 84%.

Broken in the wild

Files that opened after repair, of 234

Office47%
LibreOffice76%
Us77%

Files broken for real, not by us: crash reports, fuzzing finds and security test cases. None crashed the service.

By format

Content recovered

Share of the original's words and numbers each tool got back from damaged files.
Content recovered from damaged files, by format: Microsoft Office repair, LibreOffice repair, I Hate Corrupt Files
FormatFilesContent recovered
.xlsx72
34%
35%
75%
.docx60
57%
54%
87%
.pptx72
72%
51%
86%
.xls60
71%
68%
82%
.doc60
67%
84%
91%
.ppt60
20%
30%
63%
Method

How it was run

Damaged files
384 copies of real files from the Apache POI test files, each broken one of 12 ways files really break: cut off, bad sectors, flipped bits, an overwritten header, a lost index, an interrupted save, a text-mode transfer.
Broken in the wild
234 files from LibreOffice's broken-file test suite (the qa/**/pass and qa/**/fail folders).
Office
Microsoft 365 for Mac 16.113: the file opened, the "recover the contents" prompt accepted.
LibreOffice
LibreOffice 26.8, in its repair mode.
Opens
The result opens in Microsoft Office with no prompt.
Also · 24 September 2026

Us vs OfficeCLI

OfficeCLI checks files rather than repairing them, so the question is different: does it find the real faults, and does it leave good files alone?
Real spreadsheets

False alarms on 5,342 workbooks Excel opens

Us0
OfficeCLI239

From xlsx-corpus-bench, each verified to open in Excel. OfficeCLI v1.0.152 rejected 4.5% of them.· lower is betterDataset

Broken files

Faults found, of 133

Us133
OfficeCLI100

A 156-case fault corpus plus files written by common libraries. We repaired 104 of 104 fixable files; OfficeCLI reports but doesn't repair.

See it on your own file.

Repair a file